Sydney, 29th July, 2014
I am perturbed with some commentary whereby some people including Senator Sarah Hanson-Young are casting indirect aspersion on how India treats refugees. (http://tinyurl.com/k239hsr) Points are being made that India is not a signatory county to UN Refugees Convention. Some of them have mentioned even terrorist group ISIS (Islamic State of Iraq and A-Sham) in the same paragraph. ISIS executes people in cold-blood, and is hurting and subjugating people from religions other than their Sunni sect of Islam. This, even indirect aspersion, is inappropriate and offensive. India is not ISIS and can not even be remotely equated with it.
India is a vibrant and the biggest democracy of the world. It has rule of law with free judiciary and totally free media. It has refugees from Sri Lanka, Burma, Bangladesh, China and many other countries. It has a proud and long history of welcoming persecuted people from all corners of the world. Parsis (Zoroastrians) left Persia because they were persecuted. Dalai Lama and thousands of Tibetans exiles have lived in India for several decades without any persecution or troubles. India treats refugees humanly and with care. India may not be a signatory to UN Refugees convention, but its treatment of those who claim refuge is exemplary. UNHCR (United Nation’s High Commission for Refugees) itself has said this about India many times. India lets UNHCR do the assessment about people’s refugee status, which is fair, appropriate and prudent.
Raising concerns about India’s credentials as a caring society is objectionable.
Coming to the current issue of 157 boat people (all likely to be Sri Lankan Tamils) who were intercepted by Australian Navy just outside its Maritime zone about a month ago, it is clear that the Boat has come from Indian Shores. From all the information, it is clear that they are all Sri Lankan Tamils, who were in a refugee camp near Pondicherry, South India. India is affected in multiple ways and is a concerned party. Its shores were used as the launching pad for this boat to Australia. India needs to know who these people are and how did they use Indian shores for launching the voyage to Australia.
It is a security issue for India. India has an ongoing issue with Pakistan, from where terrorists enter Indian territories to perpetrate terrorist attacks in India. I am not saying that the boat in question is carrying terrorists, but not being concerned and alarmed with this type of voyage will render India a hypocrite. India has a right to figure out who these people are and what is the exact composition of these people.
Australia and India are friendly countries, and have strategic relations. I am pleased that Australian Minister for Immigration & Border Control, Scott Morrison, visited India recently and had a discussion with Indian Foreign Affairs Minister, Smt Sushma Swaraj. He was able to get an undertaking from Indian Govt that it will take back these people if they are Indian citizens and residents. That is a huge achievement for Australia.
India will not, and should not, allow its territories to be used as the launch pad for things which are against any other nation. In this case, it is the stated policy of Australia that they do not want to entertain illegal maritime arrivals. Current Federal Govt took the policy of “Stop the boats” to people during 2013 election and received a mandate. Previous Govt led by Julia Gillard/Kevin Rudd too had this policy. Offshore processing of illegal maritime arrivals has been the policy of Govts of both political persuasions.
Australia can not afford to have the repetition of 5000 people arriving every month, claiming refugee status. We do not have the money to afford their accommodation, food, health and education. Our national Budget is in deficit and our economy is in stress. We have to look after our elderly, homeless and less fortunate people first. We have to look after our disadvantaged people first.
Australia should accept its fair share of refugees, but there is no way it can afford an unlimited number of people who want to come to our shores with refugee claim. Australia is a caring and generous society, but there is a limit to it.
I am concerned that some people decide to come to Australia from countries where they were not facing persecution. India is definitely one such country. There is no persecution programme for anyone in India. Indians generally, free Indian media and independent judiciary will not let this happen either.
About the people in the Boat, who have now been brought to Curtin Detention Centre, I am not sure that they faced any persecution in India. Based on the prevalent governance and political system, it is unlikely they faced any persecution in India. They were living in the area ie Tamil Nadu, which is the homeland of Tamils in India.
This fact alone makes it likely that they are economic refugees, not genuine refugees.
If there is any Indian national in this group of people, then they should be sent back to India without any delay, because their claim for refugee status will be bogus, preposterous and baseless.
Australia has all the rights to refuse to accept economic refugees. Australia has all the sovereign rights to control flow of illegal maritime arrivals. Australia in fact has an undeniable responsibility to look after its disadvantaged people before allocating billions on people who are not Australia’s primary responsibility.
I see no problem in Australia working with India to figure out who these people are, where they have come from and why have they come to our shores in this manner.
Australia has full rights to send them to the country from where they have come from if they are not genuine refugees.
Australia has a well-stated and bipartisan policy of offshore processing and not settling illegal maritime arrivals in Australia. Australia does not encourage illegal maritime arrivals. It has been working with nations in the region to stop the illegal maritime arrivals. This is the first boat which has been allowed to land on our shores in over 7 months, presumably to allow sufficient time to Indian officials to process information and cross-check it.
Australia is within its rights to work with nations in our region to achieve the stated policy goals. I am in full support of these goals. I know many others, in fact a majority of Australians, are in support of these goals.
Finally, India should not allow anyone, under any circumstance, to use its shores or territories as a launch pad for voyage as “illegal maritime arrival” to Australia or any other country!
Dr Yadu Singh
Australian’s lack of wisdom best indicated in comparing India with ISIS. It shows their hate for India.
Indian diaspora is partly resp. for this who couldnt better the perception given cheeky std. Of living they adopt there. I lived in Sydney fr brief period of time, in midst of racist attacks, found Indians unfriendly, unwelcoming, keep-away attitude.
Finally, if 150 SL refugees reach Aus, shores how dare Aus makes it as our issue. Let them disc with SL as why they bcame refugees in their own country. In this whole issue, if India accepted to take back those guys, shows our magnanimity and hence, doesnt deserve hate of Aus politicos.
Keep the hate with you.
I doubt Australian politicians hate India. If we smell any such thing, we will respond to it. One Senator saying something stupid does not mean all politicians have views which are adverse to India.
Well Said Dr. Singh, but you need to acknowledge that no country will open its boundaries for illegal migrants or terrorist. India paid the biggest price for gaps in the border security in Bombay Taj attack. yes more focus can be made to Indian shores.
Thank you. India can not allow its borders being crossed in this manner by either who are entering or leaving the country. It is a major security breach for India!
Spot on, Australian Indian.
I agree entirely with you. Sri Lankan Tamils are disgracing our Country. Australian media/politician should appreciate the Indian festure.
India is not responsible if a group of Tamil refugees leave in a boat for Australian shores. How can the Indian customs authorities tell if the boat is going for fishing or for ferrying people to Australia illegally. The problem of Tamil refugees is ingrained in the unfair treatment of Tamils In Sri Lanka. It has been the standard strategy of the Western developed nations to say nothing of the refugee problem faced by India from Tibet, Bangla Desh and Sri Lanka, and assume that it does not exist, till such time that they have to face the music. If Australia is concerned about the Tamil refugee problem then it cannot force the Indian government to control the exodus of the Tamils from refugee camps. These camps are not concentration camps, like those of Australia in Nauru and Manus islands. These camps are allowing the interns freedom of ingress and egress. India cannot police them and is in no way responsible if some of these refugees take a boat to Australia.