Outraged with ugly head of racism.

Recently, we have seen a couple of  racist comments in Australia and NZ which had bothered us. Indians were the targets in these cases.

First was the example of the ill-mannered journo named Paul Henry from TV NZ [National TV of NZ] making grossly offensive comments and laughing at the surname of Delhi chief minister, Mrs Sheila Dixit. Even his colleagues were uncomfortable with his comments. I have no doubt that his comments were uncivilized and racist in nature. It showed quite clearly that his upbringing was less than perfect. Indians and Indian Govt were justifiably outraged with his comments. Indian Foreign Minister, Mr SM Krishna was right to summon NZ High Commissioner to his office and convey India’s displeasure.


That Paul Henry is racist against Indians is evidenced by his further utterances. NZ’s Governor General, Sir Ananad Satyanand is of Indian heritage. He was born in Auckland. Despite that, Henry did not think Sir Satyanand was a true New Zealander. How so? Is he not a true New Zealander because he is not White or PAKEHA as Maori people call White people in NZ? It just makes one wonder about Henry’s thinking.

If this was not enough, a NZ radio host, Michael Laws, made some disparaging comments about the Governor General [GG] of NZ, Sir Anand Satyanand’s body size and mentioned something about India and begging. He too showed his racist thinking. His comments were particularly uncivil  as they were about the Head of NZ Government. I would have expected that the GG would be held with high regards by the citizens of NZ.


Look, I have some personal experiences in NZ. While a vast majority of  New Zealanders are decent people, I found that a small proportion of  New Zealanders are ignorant and openly racist. They have a superiority complex over Non-White people. Is it due to the fact that they have subjugated indigenous people [Maori] for centuries and until recently, they were not used to the people from all over the World who would not allow anyone to treat them unfairly? To such ignorant and racist people, I say “grow up”. They need to be confronted assertively.

While we were fuming over misbehaviour from New Zealanders, we get the news of racist comments by some officers in Victoria Police. They were making insensitive comments via emails on a video depicting electrocution of an Indian man over the roof of a train in India and suggesting that it might be a method to fix Melbourne’s Indian students’ issues. Indians and India Govt were again outraged. Indian Minister, Mr Krishna was right to call Australia’s High Commissioner, Mr Peter Varghese to his office and express India’s outrage. He was right because he was concerned about the behaviour of  some from Vic Police force which is supposed to help every one irrespective of the race, gender and nationality of those who are seeking help. Racist views among Police officers will not generate a sense of confidence among people. I was somewhat heartened to note that Victorian Premier and Police commissioner have condemned these police officers, some of whom have been sacked, and some have been fined upto $3000 and placed on a good behaviour bond. Some have quit the Victoria Police themselves, sensing problems in ongoing investigation by Vic Police.  Investigation is on against some more. Vic Police and any other Police force must have ZERO TOLERANCE to racism and racist views among anyone who is part of the Police force.

There are many more examples which I can give but the point has been made. The point is that there are some racist people in Australia and NZ. I do say it with confidence however that a vast majority of people are fair-minded and not racist. This is true of Police forces too. I don’t want to create an impression that we are living in a racist society. Unfortunately, we have racist people all over the world. No country is the exception. India is no exception either. Raj Thakeray is a very clear example. We must remain rational and balanced. We must react proportionately. This is very much applicable to Indian media too.

The scourge of racism is not going to be removed from the world any time soon. There will always be mentally sick people who think their race to be superior to other races. We can’t do much about what people think as long as they are not acting on their beliefs. This is obviously not permitted for those who are in the Police and security agencies. Racist beliefs are a big “No” for Police officials. Police agencies should run campaigns among their personnel to educate them against racism and racist views. Police agencies should be on a look out for any such tendency and Police officers should dob racist officers in, simply because decent and fair-minded Police officers [vast majority] must not allow a small minority among them to tarnish their image. I would like to remind people that Police officers are consistently graded as one of the most trusted people in Australia. This image must be maintained and like Vic Police, they should take firm and severe actions if any one is found to hold racist views or acting in a racist manner.

In case of  NZ  journos, they should be sacked from their jobs by their employers as they are not suitable for their positions. A broadcaster can’t be allowed to behave the way these two cretins did.

I have liked what Minister SM Krishna has done. It was clearly warranted.

As far as we, Indian Australians, are concerned, we should make our concerns and displeasure known in no uncertain terms. We will need to network with other communities and fair-minded Australians [and they are in majority]. We will also need to identify people among ourselves who have a clear capacity to think, lead,  network with others, and communicate. These issues are clearly of national in nature and we will therefore need a national structure to deal with these issues.  We will need to be more organised. The very same strategy should be applicable for NZ or any other country.

Yadu Singh/Sydney/12th October, 2010

www.twitter.com/dryadusingh                                                         www.facebook.com                                                                         www.yadusingh.wordpress.com

7 thoughts on “Outraged with ugly head of racism.

  1. Dear Dr. Singh
    Liked your blog. Thanks for bringing up a subject which a lot us Indian-Australians as well as white australians hesitate to discuss about. And that is precisely what needs to be done. Australia needs to become “comfortable” with discussing racial issues; tackle them head-on rather than talk in hushed tone about it. No need to feel defensive about that nor blindly deny that it exists. No country is immune to racism as it is human to discriminate. However, those who want to call themselves civilized, must learn to be so as racism is an index of lack of improvement in a community’s understanding itself. Having said that, often lack of exposure to a different culture can result in a “defensive behaviour” that could be misconstrued as racism. I have come across both types living in Australia. As you rightly say, by and large Australians are fair minded; sometimes more than what I experienced living in India. But definately lot more education is needed for the community to understand what could be difficult for migrant population to accept. An attitude of “take it or leave it” is a clear indication of lack of progress. I must confess though, in 15 years I have been living here I have seen lots of changes in perception not only in local population but also migrants who integrate better. At the end of the day, integration is great if you end up trading your bad for someone’s good. That can perhaps put an end to this perception about racism. And integration is no one way street. The system needs to be flexible as much as new entrants to accommodate diffent variables. Thanks again for a stinulating topic and your courage to put it in black and white; no pun intended!!


  2. Dear Dr Singh,

    I am sincerly perplexed by your comment that racist people are ‘mentally ill’. As a highly educated member of our community, you should be aware that racism is a natural thought process which is an unfortunate gift from our primitive ancestors.

    We cannot continue to hold the remainder of the community for racist behaviour. If we take a more active role in the society, I sincerly believe people will be less inclined to engage in such primitive behaviour.

    Furthermore, much has been written about Australia’s racist views towards Indian students. However, very little has been exposed regarding their poor behaviour. Many Indian students have married Australian citizens and left them dry after receiving citizenship. Many have also fathered children and left these women.


  3. Yadu, I agree with your points except the one on Raj Thackrey. Clearly he is not a racist in the real sense. He cannot claim he is supperior to Biharis or other Indians on the basis of race as he is as Indian as the rest. He has prejudice against people from other states and that is not racial.
    Put it simply, all Indians are of the same race and one cannot claim superiority over aother.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s